Home » Other

Advantages and disadvantages of inflating tires with nitrogen

There are also opponents of the method who completely reject all the arguments of its supporters. Their main argument is the well-known fact that air consists of 78% nitrogen, 21% oxygen and other gases. Question: why pump in an additional 15% nitrogen? It is unlikely that an additional volume of gas will be able to radically improve the performance characteristics of a car tire. Moreover, this service costs more.

Let's understand the situation, consider all the pros and cons of nitrogen in tires.

History of technology

In the automotive world, they started pumping nitrogen into tires quite a long time ago. True, this method was first used in the “royal” class of auto racing - Formula 1. However, like most other technologies, they are tested on race cars before manufacturers begin using them on production cars. In this case, an air-nitrogen mixture was used, rather than pure gas. The method was first used in the middle of the last century.

In the case of Formula 1, using this method provides at least one big advantage - increased safety. The fact is that if the car catches fire, the air from the burst tire acts as an oxygen supply, fueling the flame even more. If nitrogen is pumped into tires, this effect will no longer occur, meaning the risk of fire is reduced.

In the United States, nitrogen is used instead of air in tires in commercial vehicles. This is not a mandatory rule; many truck owners and carriers simply use alternative options.

Read also:  Do-it-yourself CV joint puller: design and principle of operation, types, drawings and step-by-step instructions

In everyday life, cars are not often used to the limit of their capabilities, and fires occur very rarely. Therefore, it is not advisable to pump gas instead of air just for the sake of greater safety, but there are other advantages.

How is it really?

The most interesting thing is that many services offer pumping not pure nitrogen into tires, but nitrogen-based mixtures, where this gas occupies 90-95 % of the mixture.

The presence of special gas generators really makes it possible to achieve such a percentage, but not all service stations have these generators.

Moreover, these same services claim that their mixture is unique and it is absolutely forbidden to add air or another mixture to it.

But the same gas generator is only capable of removing oxygen and other substances from the air.

That is, the initial gas is the same air, and adding it to nitrogen or a mixture based on it pumped into the tire will not change anything.

Nevertheless, many car owners believe in these positive qualities of nitrogen and cite one of the most basic arguments as proof - the car “runs” softer.

But in reality, often such an obvious advantage is just a banal underinflation of the tires to the required pressure level.

As a result, the tire absorbs road irregularities more on itself, rather than transmitting them to the suspension.

But underinflation has significantly more negative qualities - the contact patch of the tire with the road is larger, which leads to more intense wear and also increases consumption.

Advantages of the method

Inflating tires with nitrogen has both supporters and opponents. Moreover, they are present among professionals, including owners of tire stations and service stations, and among amateurs. The advantages of the method include:

  • no gas leakage - wheels flatten less;
  • reduced wheel weight - lower fuel consumption;
  • no tire overheating;
  • increased security;
  • stable tire pressure;
  • slowing down the aging of rubber wheel elements;

Introduction

Relatively recently, a new tempting offer has appeared in many service centers in Russia - inflating tires with nitrogen. It is worth noting right away that the service does not have domestic roots; a similar method is used in Europe and the USA for refilling tires of commercial vehicles or buses. The operating rules of any car do not say about the need for this procedure; most likely, this is the choice of the car owner himself. For the first time, wheels began to be pumped with nitrogen during Formula 1 races. A mixture of nitrogen and air filled the tires of racing cars, although according to the regulations for high-speed racing it is allowed to drive on ordinary air. Every car enthusiast has the right to decide for himself whether he needs such a procedure or not. If you listen to the opinion of the employees of the service station where this service is provided, nitrogen refilling is simply necessary, and the car owner will be told about the mass of advantages gained. However, most automotive experts are confident that this is nothing more than a new marketing ploy that allows service centers to simply siphon extra money from unscrupulous motorists. Let's deal with everything in order.

Reduced fuel consumption

This is one of the most common reasons for using nitrogen instead of air. Its essence boils down to the fact that the specified gas is lighter than air, and accordingly, less weight of the wheel will lead to lower fuel consumption.

Read also:  Checking the oil pressure in a Priora 16-valve engine with your own hands

To do this, you need to understand the real numbers. A cubic meter of air that is pumped into tires weighs 1.29 kg, and a cubic meter of gas weighs 1.25 kg. A standard passenger car wheel holds about 75 grams of pure gas and 77 grams of air mixture. Therefore, the difference between fully inflated wheels will be a few grams, which is negligible for significant fuel savings.

The difference is almost unnoticeable - dirt between the treads or pebbles add much more weight to the wheel.

Real alternative

  • Timely seasonal tire replacement that meets both legal requirements and common sense. Summer tires definitely roll easier!
  • Before long trips on the highway, increase the tire pressure by 0.2 bar. It will be a little tougher, but noticeably more economical.
  • Use lightweight wheels, not just any alloy wheels, but preferably forged ones; they often have a noticeably lower weight. In general, choose wheels not by design, but by weight. But to ensure lightness without sacrificing durability, look for certified rims.
  • Use tires made using Energy saver technology.
    Many manufacturers have these today. They have slightly lower rolling resistance thanks to the use of technologies designed specifically for resource conservation.
  • Choose tires using the results of the “Behind the Wheel” tire tests,
    where each candidate’s rolling resistance is measured, among other things.
  • Install light-alloy (and really light) wheels of a larger diameter
    and select the appropriate tires using a tire calculator, while maintaining the outer diameter of the previous wheel. Well, or a little more.
  • You drive a lot on the highway, but with a light load, or the gears in your car’s gearbox can be called “short”, such as, for example, in the Renault Logan or Lada Largus. That is, at 100 km/h the engine makes more than 3000 rpm in top gear. Then you can install tires with a slightly larger diameter.
    This will make all gears a little longer and will save fuel.

Popular tire models

Wheels flatten less

Stable pressure is another argument for fans to pump nitrogen into the wheel instead of regular air. In this case, the argument is the larger size of the gas molecule compared to the size of the oxygen molecule. Accordingly, oxygen seeps through microscopic cracks and holes in the tire faster. As a result, the pressure drops and the tire goes flat.

Yes it is. But do not forget that ordinary atmospheric air consists of 78% nitrogen, and only 21% oxygen. Therefore, when the pressure in the wheel drops, it is pumped up, thus adding even more nitrogen from ordinary air. After several years of operation, the wheel is almost completely inflated with gas alone.

Advertising stunt

At a branded expensive tire service, almost any car owner, and especially the owner, will probably be offered to inflate their tires with nitrogen. There are a lot of arguments in favor of this procedure. Let's figure out which of them are true and which are fiction:

  1. The tire pressure will be stable because nitrogen hardly expands when heated.
    But the air already contains 78% nitrogen, so the changes account for the rest of the gases, which also do not expand beyond measure. The difference in the coefficient of volumetric expansion is negligible with a significant figure in the fourth decimal place.
  2. Nitrogen molecules are larger and therefore do not penetrate outward through the tire walls as quickly, keeping the pressure stable.
    But do not forget that there is not so much oxygen with other gases - about 22%. And when they begin to evaporate, and we begin to pump up the tire, the nitrogen concentration will increase. So, a 5-6-year-old wheel develops an almost purely nitrogen “atmosphere” inside.
  3. A wheel filled with nitrogen is lighter than a wheel inflated with atmospheric air.
    This saves fuel. Simple calculations show that the wheel of a mid-size crossover will be lighter by only a few grams. How much do the pebbles stuck in the tread weigh? Let's clean the tread more often, especially since tire design engineers highly recommend it.
  4. The absence of oxygen protects the tire material from premature aging.
    Tire manufacturers support this thesis, but you don’t hope that after a century your tires will be located on a pedestal, like the wheels of Lenin’s armored car. Wear and aging of the outer layers of rubber under the influence of the sun, ozone, and moisture occurs much faster.
  5. Better road grip and greater safety due to stable performance.
    I don’t agree: you still need to check the tire pressure periodically, and with each “puff” precious nitrogen will be released. And you can’t let yourself down. This is how servicemen strive to tie a car enthusiast to their workshop even for such an insignificant problem as checking pressure and inflating a tire.

Air or nitrogen: other advantages, “imaginary” or obvious.

Nitrogen practically does not expand when heated, so the pressure in the wheel will remain constant as the temperature changes. In contrast to this statement, it is worth noting that more than three quarters of the air is nitrogen. Other gases also do not expand much, so the difference in pressure between tires filled with air or nitrogen when heated is not too great to be taken into account.

Proponents of the method argue that the absence of oxygen provides additional protection to the material from aging. Yes, this is a fair point, but does it make any practical sense? Rubber is exposed to other factors - aggressive environments, moisture, sunlight, and so on. All this does not contribute to extending the service life, but no one is going to use tires forever. There are certain temporary operating indicators on which the gas used does not have any significant impact.

A lower noise level is indicated by a tire into which pure gas is pumped rather than atmospheric air. Yes, through simple measurements at a speed of 100 km/h, the noise level in the first case is 65 dB versus 68 dB in the second. Is it good or bad? It's just not noticeable - a difference of 3 dB is absolutely insignificant.

A wheel filled with nitrogen is less likely to explode. In fact, the wheel will explode only if the car is used mercilessly, which occurs very rarely in ordinary life. Moreover, in fact, the wheel does not explode, but bursts - there is a sharp loss of pressure when the tire structure is destroyed. And this can happen when hitting an object or obstacle.

Also, you should not pay serious attention to the advice of those who recommend checking the pressure in the tire with nitrogen less. Checking should be done as often as the manufacturer recommends, and the number of checks does not depend on the type of mixture. How long a wheel “holds” is largely influenced by the composition of the rubber and its condition. A normal tire can hold pressure for years without damage.

But metal corrosion is more pronounced when air is used. The oxygen it contains is an oxidizing agent. It enters into a chemical oxidation reaction even at low temperatures, affecting the wheel and rubber. This statement can be attributed to the truly positive aspects of nitrogen injection.

Flaws

The downside to using nitrogen instead of air in your car's tires may be the cost. After all, the technology involves removing air from the wheel and then pumping clean gas in its place. Naturally, you need to think carefully about whether it is necessary to pump in nitrogen, and whether it would be better to use the traditional method. We did not find any significant advantages; representatives of the main tire brands have a similar opinion. To determine why to do this, you need to think carefully, because there are no pronounced advantages.

Another disadvantage is the need to use special equipment; gas cylinders are also needed. Only special car service centers and tire shops can afford this. Any car owner can inflate a tire with a compressor or even a simple pump; you don’t have to be a professional to do this. This will not work with nitrogen - you will not be able to pump gas in a garage or in the middle of a highway, at least without the appropriate equipment.

The following drawback cannot be called a pure disadvantage of the method, but nevertheless its opponents often talk about it. The essence of their refutation is that in plain air the nitrogen content is at least 78%, so there is no point in pumping in an additional 15%.

An argument in favor of using nitrogen in tires is the smooth running of the vehicle. There is no obvious evidence of this advantage, it’s just that the pressure in this case is a little less - the wheel is underinflated, which ensures smooth movement on uneven road surfaces.

An obvious myth is the statement that when a tire is punctured, gas comes out more slowly than clean air. The reason for this is the larger size of its molecule. This is not true, and any puncture can “empty” the wheel in a matter of moments.

For example, in the rules of the notorious Formula 1, the elite of motorsport, there is no mandatory requirement to use exclusively nitrogen. The opportunity to choose is provided, which means that there are no advantages of one method over another. For road cars the situation is similar, but with one clarification. The cost of using nitrogen in vehicle tires is much higher and this is a significant disadvantage. The question arises - why overpay if there are no advantages as such? The answer depends solely on the preferences of the individual car owner.

“Price from” means the minimum (estimated) price for the product provided by GOODYEAR dealers in the Customs Union who have expressed a desire to post this information on this resource. Minimum price may vary by region and/or dealer. The final price for the product is calculated on the website of the corresponding dealer and may differ from that stated on this resource. The materials presented on this site are for informational purposes only and do not constitute a public offer in accordance with Article 437 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation.

*Check with your applicable GOODYEAR dealer for terms and conditions of each current promotion. The materials presented on this site are for informational purposes only and do not constitute a public offer in accordance with Article 437 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation

Source

Rating
( 2 ratings, average 5 out of 5 )
Did you like the article? Share with friends:
You may also be interested
Tubeless tires: design, advantages and disadvantages
Features of GDI engines
Design, principle of operation, advantages and disadvantages of GDI engines
Features, advantages and disadvantages of the TFSI motor
Automatic transmission for VAZ 2112: advantages and disadvantages
Reviews of Lada X Ray 1.6 liter with manual transmission: advantages, disadvantages, is it worth buying
We cover the car body with wax: advantages and disadvantages
Advantages and disadvantages in the interior of the Vesta SW Cross station wagon
DSG box what is it
What is a DSG gearbox - advantages and disadvantages of a double-clutch gearbox
what gives negative camber
Negative wheel camber: why is it needed, advantages and disadvantages
Rating of the best clutch manufacturers. How to choose, advantages and disadvantages
How to set up Starline a64: main characteristics, advantages and disadvantages of the device
Gas-powered diesel engine: operating features, advantages and disadvantages of gas-diesel
For any suggestions regarding the site: [email protected]
Для любых предложений по сайту: [email protected]