In the footsteps of Wankel: the rise and fall of VAZ rotary engines

The VAZ-415 car with a rotary engine was initially perceived as a comic experiment. According to the developers, the “nine” with such an engine could outrun a Mercedes at a speed of 200 km/h. Nevertheless, there is some part of the truth in this. The power unit in question surpassed all standard modifications of the domestic automotive industry in terms of dynamic and speed parameters. Let's figure out what the advantages and differences of this device are from conventional internal combustion engines.

general information

For the first time in Russia, the VAZ-415 with a rotary engine appeared in 1996 on the basis of the VAZ-2109. The vehicle differed from its competitors in its increased power performance. An experimental 140 horsepower engine accelerated the car to 100 km/h in just eight seconds. At the same time, the speed threshold was about 200 km/h.

The capacity of the fuel tank is 39 liters, fuel consumption has increased noticeably. A full refueling was enough for a trip from Moscow to Smolensk and back. The fact that the car did not go into mass production is explained by its solid “appetite”, as well as its high cost. After the starting prototype, manufacturers released two more copies: versions with 150 and 250 “horses”. The increased dynamics in practical terms did not provide anything useful. The engine, boosted in all respects, became completely unusable after 40 thousand kilometers.

Reliability, weaknesses, maintainability

Reliability

Despite many unfinished aspects, the VAZ-415 is considered a reliable engine. This was clearly expressed on one of the cut forums from Novosibirsk. He writes: “... the engine is simple, relatively reliable, but the problem is with spare parts and prices...”.

An indicator of reliability is the mileage before major repairs. The resource declared by the manufacturer was rarely maintained, but there were interesting facts in the history of the motor.

Thus, the magazine “Behind the Wheel” describes the situation with the rotary engine installed on the RAF. It is emphasized, “... the engine finally wore out after 120 thousand km, and the rotor was virtually beyond repair...”.

Private car owners also have experience in long-term operation of internal combustion engines. There is information that the unit provided a mileage of over 300 thousand km without major repairs.

The second main factor indicating reliability is the safety margin. The VAZ-415 has an impressive one. Just one installation of an injector increases engine power by more than 2.5 times. The interesting thing is that the engine can easily withstand high speeds. So, spinning up to 10 thousand revolutions is not the limit for it (operational - 6 thousand).

The AvtoVAZ design bureau is constantly working to improve the reliability of the unit. Thus, the problem of increasing the efficiency of bearing units, gas and oil seals, and warping of the metal of housing units due to their different heating was solved.

The VAZ-415 is characterized as a reliable engine, but only if it is cared for promptly and thoroughly.

Weak spots

The VAZ-415 has the weaknesses of its predecessors. First of all, car owners are not satisfied with the high oil and fuel consumption. This is a feature of a rotary engine, and you have to come to terms with it.

On this occasion, car enthusiast wooden_goblin from Makhachkala writes: “... it’s true that the oil consumption is almost a liter per 1000, and the oil needs to be changed every 5000, and spark plugs every 10,000... Well, spare parts are manufactured in only two factories...”.

Phillip J echoes his sentiments: “...the most unpleasant thing is not frugality. The rotary V8 consumes 15 liters of gasoline per 100 km. On the other hand, the engine, as its developers claim, doesn’t care what it’s powered by: be it 98 or 76...”

The special design of the combustion chamber does not allow all surfaces of the internal combustion engine to have the same temperature. Therefore, inattentive and aggressive driving often leads to overheating of the unit.

The high level of toxicity of exhaust gases is of no small importance. For a number of reasons, the engine does not comply with environmental standards adopted in Europe. Here we must pay tribute to the manufacturer - work in this direction is underway.

The process of servicing the motor causes great inconvenience. Most service stations do not accept such internal combustion engines. The reason is that there are no specialists working on rotary engines.

In practice, there are only two car services where you can properly service or repair the unit. One is located in Moscow, the second in Tolyatti.

Maintainability

The VAZ-415 is simple in design, but not one that can be repaired in any garage. Firstly, there is a certain problem with finding spare parts. Secondly, the unit reacts very painfully to the quality of parts. The slightest discrepancy leads to its failure.

One of the available options is to purchase a contract engine. It’s easy to find sellers of rotary internal combustion engines on the Internet. At the same time, you need to be prepared for the fact that the cost of these internal combustion engines is quite high.

Despite the promise of rotary engines, production of the VAZ-415 was discontinued. One (and perhaps the most important) of the reasons was the high cost of its production.

Historical facts

The unique VAZ-415 unit had a rotary engine, which was of interest to Soviet officials back in 1974. Trying to improve momentum in the automotive industry, the government decided to take a big risk. A special design bureau is being created at the plant in Togliatti, the main task of which is to create serial Wankel engines, as rotary units were also called.

Since VAZ models initially copied the Italian Fiat, the engineers in the new version decided to take the Mazda engine as a basis. Domestic injection developments fell into oblivion, although this was the wrong decision, as it turned out later. Soviet officials themselves began negotiations directly with Wankel on the issue of acquiring a license. They were unsuccessful because the designer asked for a huge fee. However, some technologies have been successfully copied.

The pioneer model in this segment was the VAZ-311 with 65 horsepower. The pilot series was released only five years later. 50 copies of the VAZ-415 rotary engine rolled off the assembly line. The models sold successfully among plant workers and government bigwigs.

Police penny: RPDs were also placed on these

0
Source:

However, despite the failure with the VAZ-21018, work on creating a RPD was further developed - domestic law enforcement agencies needed a powerful engine, while the requirements for service life and fuel consumption were lower than for a general purpose vehicle. As a result, the Zhiguli VAZ-21019 (also based on the VAZ-21011 body) with a two-section VAZ-411 RPD with a power of 120 hp was created. at 6000 rpm. The maximum speed of this car, which was called “Arkan,” was 160 km/h. On October 20, 1982, under the leadership of the USSR Minister of Automotive Industry V.N. Polyakov, a meeting was held on the work of the AvtoVAZ design bureau on rotary piston engines, automotive prospects for the use of VAZ RPDs and the possibility of organizing their mass production. As a result of the meeting, it was decided to begin organizing serial production of automotive RPDs for special operational vehicles in 1983, and to determine a production program for RPDs at VAZ for 1983 in the amount of 200 units per year.

Peculiarities

The updated engine did not gain much popularity, since it had only a Japanese lining, and the internals quickly failed. The units had to be changed to piston analogues, in general the idea failed.

Nevertheless, the engine received an unexpected second life. After the next proposal, the plant began production of the VAZ-415 two-section rotary engine with a capacity of 120 horsepower. The resurrected domestically produced unit became so attractive that they began to order it for sports cars and water transport. Vehicles with the specified power units won prizes, far ahead of vehicles with standard pistons. Most likely, it was this fact that became the reason for the ban on the production of this engine. The next attempt at resuscitation occurred after the collapse of the Union in 1996, as mentioned above.

Archive photo of factory tests of VAZ-21018

0
Source:

A series of fifty such cars was produced to test them in real operating conditions. Soon, within six months, the plant was forced to replace the RPD with conventional internal combustion engines on 49 out of 50 cars, which was associated with a colossal number of complaints about the quality of both the design itself and its execution. The main malfunctions were failure of seals and bearing units, insufficient balance of the rotor-eccentric mechanism (REM), and low fuel efficiency.

Advantages

The VAZ-415 rotary engine, the photo of which is presented below, has become an excellent alternative to a forced engine. Among the advantages:

• stable power indicator throughout the entire operating range;
• huge potential for chip tuning;
• high efficiency;
• speed up to 10,000 rotations per minute.

The operating principle of the unit in question differs from a standard internal combustion engine. First of all, this is due to the presence of a rotor, which performs the duties of a connecting rod and piston. The incoming energy from fuel combustion provokes the rotation of the shaft at high speed. Inlet and outlet occur in a single compartment, the inside of which resembles a capsule. The rotor was mounted on a shaft and was firmly engaged with a gear, which is connected to the stator.

Rotary aggregate and everything connected with it

This motor has constantly attracted and is attracting maximum attention not only in the vastness of our Motherland. And this is not surprising: the design of such a power unit is very simple, and the characteristics seem to be under the hood of not one, but two motors, but, as in our case, this unit has not taken root anywhere. The creator of such a motor is called Wankel, who managed to come up with this design back in 1919. Wankel was German and at the age of 17 he created a miracle. How he managed this remains a mystery. DKM or “machine with rotating pistons” is the name given to the first car with a rotary unit, the first patent for which Wankel received in 1929.

Operating principle

Rotary engine in the VAZ 2109 and its operating principle

The rotary engine today is called an excellent alternative to a highly boosted engine. This unit has the following advantages:

• Constant power throughout the entire range of engine operation;
• Huge potential for boosting (chip tuning);
• Incredibly high efficiency (with 1 liter of working volume it is possible to squeeze out about 110 hp even without chip tuning);
• Although in the case of the VAZ 2109 the engineers were unable to achieve efficiency, the rotary engine, in fact, can consume relatively little (there is a chance to repeat the experience with the “nine”);
• Cars with a rotary unit are capable of developing high speeds (up to 10,000 per minute).

The operating principle of this miracle unit is as follows:

• It is strikingly different from the operation of a piston internal combustion engine, as this is due to design features. Among the main differences is the rotor itself, which plays both the role of a piston and the role of a connecting rod;
• In such units, the entire crankshaft mechanism is reduced to only the rotor and shaft. The fuel energy forces the shaft to rotate at high speed.

Interesting. It is noteworthy that fuel supply, shaft rotation and the rest occur in one block, which is both the combustion chamber and the timing belt.

• All important processes take place in a single block: intake and exhaust;
• The block itself is shaped like a capsule from the inside. In science, this form has its own name - epitrochoid;
• There is a rotor mounted on the shaft. It is firmly coupled to the gear, which in turn is connected to the stator.

Wankel and its engine

Note. You should know that the rotor is much larger than the stator, but despite this, it rotates easily with the gear.

• The rotor has a triangle shape. Moving along the inner surface of the block, the triangle (or rather, each of its ends) cuts off a certain amount of space;
• As for the piston rings, in a rotary unit their function is performed by special plates that are pressed against the walls of the block by band springs, gas pressure and centrifugal forces;
• The design of the Wankel engine is devoid of a complex timing belt, which greatly simplifies it;
• Due to the absence of friction losses (as we remember, this motor does not have many KVM parts - see above), it is possible to generate more power;
• In a rotary unit, for one full revolution of the rotor there are as many as three working cycles.

Note. One of the disadvantages of a rotary engine is its large appetite, which is explained, in particular, by the fact that the combustion chamber at the moment of the compression stroke is too long and the fuel does not have time to completely burn out. It is in order to combat this, to increase efficiency, that two spark plugs are installed on such engines. They fire alternately, igniting the fuel on both sides. Thanks to such measures, invented quite recently, it was possible to significantly increase the performance of the rotary unit in terms of efficiency (note to VAZ 2109 engineers).

So far, all this looks good only on paper. Using the example of the VAZ 2109 and other car models with a rotary engine, it becomes clear that success in real life is still far away. There are many cars with this engine scattered all over the world, in different parts of it. A few of them are still on the move, but most (lucky ones) are kept in museums or private collections. Many models with engines from the 60s-80s can be found in landfills.

History of the rotary engine

The shortcomings of such a rare engine today will immediately surface and discourage an ardent agitator for the introduction of a rotary internal combustion engine into automobile production as soon as we imagine the following situation.
The owner of a “nine” with a rotor found himself in an unpleasant situation: his engine overheated. What will he do? The answer is clear: rush around the city and look for specialists, rare spare parts and parts. On the other hand, the rotary engine has a future. Nobody took him away. The Wankel engine has the green light and engineers around the world will have to work hard to improve the design and eliminate most of its shortcomings. Then an ordinary piston internal combustion engine will turn out to be a weak competitor in front of a powerful rotary unit, destined for oblivion. But today it’s too early to think about it.

RPD operation scheme

Device

The rotary power unit of the VAZ-415 is made in the shape of a triangle. When moving inside the block, each end of the structure is separated by a certain amount of space. In this engine, the role of piston rings was played by special plate elements, pressed to the walls using belt-type springs, centrifugal force and exhaust gas pressure.

The design of the Wankel internal combustion engine does not include a timing belt, which significantly simplifies the design of the device. Since friction losses in this unit are minimal, it was possible to achieve a significant increase in power. Three working cycles were carried out during one full revolution.

The disadvantages of rotary engines include high fuel consumption. This is due to the fact that the combustion compartment during the compression stroke is too long, which does not allow the gasoline to burn out completely. To level out this drawback, they began installing two spark plugs on the engines, firing alternately. This approach made it possible to increase the efficiency of the updated modifications.

Advantages and disadvantages

The converted movement of a reciprocating nature is completely absent in a rotary engine. Pressure is generated in those chambers that are created using the convex surfaces of the triangular rotor and various parts of the housing. The rotor performs rotational movements with the help of combustion. This can reduce vibration and increase rotation speed. Due to the increased efficiency that results from this, the rotary engine is much smaller in size than a conventional piston engine of equivalent power.

A rotary engine has one main component among all its components. This important component is called a triangular rotor, which rotates inside the stator. All three vertices of the rotor, thanks to this rotation, have a constant connection with the inner wall of the housing. With the help of this contact, combustion chambers are formed, or three closed-type volumes with gas. When the rotor rotates inside the housing, the volume of all three formed combustion chambers changes all the time, reminiscent of the actions of a conventional pump. All three side surfaces of the rotor act like a piston.

Inside the rotor is a small gear with external teeth, which is attached to the housing. The gear, which is larger in diameter, is connected to this fixed gear, which sets the very trajectory of the rotational movements of the rotor inside the housing. The teeth in the larger gear are internal.

Due to the fact that the rotor is connected eccentrically to the output shaft, the rotation of the shaft occurs in the same way as a handle would rotate a crankshaft. The output shaft will rotate three times for each rotor revolution.

The rotary engine has the advantage of low weight. The most basic of the rotary engine blocks is small in size and weight. At the same time, the controllability and performance of such an engine will be better. It has less weight due to the fact that there is simply no need for a crankshaft, connecting rods and pistons.

The rotary engine has dimensions that are much smaller than a conventional engine of the same power. Thanks to the smaller engine size, handling will be much better, and the car itself will become more spacious, both for passengers and the driver.

All of the parts of a rotary engine perform continuous rotational movements in the same direction. Changing their movement occurs in the same way as in the pistons of a traditional engine. Rotary engines are internally balanced. This leads to a decrease in the vibration level itself. The rotary engine's power feels much smoother and more even.

The Wankel engine has a special convex rotor with three edges, which can be called its heart. This rotor performs rotational movements inside the cylindrical surface of the stator. The Mazda rotary engine is the world's first rotary engine that was developed specifically for mass production. This development began back in 1963.

Characteristics of VAZ-415

Brief parameters of the Wankel engine:

• number of sections - 2 pieces;
• power indicator - 140 hp. With.;
• unit weight - 113 kg;
• working chamber volume - 1.3 cubic meters. dm;
• overall dimensions - 570/535/665 mm;
• working life before major repairs - 125 thousand km.

It is worth noting that fuel supply, shaft rotation and other operating operations occur in a single unit, which is the combustion compartment and timing section.

Advantages and disadvantages of rotary engines

Advantages

A rotary engine is good because it consists of a much smaller number of parts

than its competitor - by 35-40 percent.

Two engines of the same power - rotary and piston - will differ greatly in size. Piston twice as big

.

The rotary motor does not experience much load at high speeds

even if you accelerate the car to a speed of more than 100 km/h in low gear.

A car with a rotary engine is easier to balance, which gives increased stability to the car.

on road.

Even the lightest of vehicles do not suffer from vibration, because the RPD vibrates much less than a piston engine.

. This occurs due to the greater balance of the RPD.

Flaws

Motorists would call the main disadvantage of the rotary engine its short resource

, which is a direct consequence of its design. Seals wear out extremely quickly, as their working angle is constantly changing.

The motor experiences temperature changes

every stroke, which also contributes to wear of the material. Add to this the pressure that is exerted on the rubbing surfaces, which can only be treated by injecting oil directly into the manifold.

Wear of seals

causes leakage between chambers whose pressure differences are too great. Because of this, engine efficiency decreases and environmental damage increases.

The crescent shape of the chambers does not contribute to the complete combustion of fuel

, and the speed of rotation of the rotor and the short length of the working stroke are the reason for pushing out gases that are still too hot, not completely burned, into the exhaust. In addition to gasoline combustion products, there is also oil present, which together makes the exhaust very toxic. Piston - causes less harm to the environment.

Exorbitant appetites

gasoline engine has already been mentioned, and it “eats” up to 1 liter of oil per 1000 km. Moreover, once you forget about the oil, you can end up with major repairs, if not an engine replacement.

High price

- due to the fact that the manufacture of a motor requires high-precision equipment and very high-quality materials.

As you can see, the rotary engine is full of shortcomings, but the piston engine is also imperfect, so the competition between them did not stop for so long. Is it over forever? Time will show.

Components and operating principle

The design of the RPD type engine is extremely simple and compact. A rotor is installed on the axis of the unit, which is firmly connected to the gear. The latter engages with the stator. The rotor, which has three sides, moves along an epitrochoidal cylindrical plane. As a result, the changing volumes of the working chambers of the cylinder are cut off using three valves. Sealing plates (end and radial type) are pressed against the cylinder under the influence of gas and due to the action of centripetal forces and band springs. This results in 3 isolated chambers of different volumetric dimensions. Here the processes of compression of the incoming mixture of fuel and air, expansion of gases, exerting pressure on the working surface of the rotor and clearing the combustion chamber of gases are carried out. The circular motion of the rotor is transmitted to the eccentric axis. The axis itself is located on bearings and transmits rotational torque to the transmission mechanisms. In these motors, two mechanical pairs operate simultaneously. One, which consists of gears, regulates the movement of the rotor itself. The other converts the rotating movement of the piston into the rotating movement of the eccentric axis.

Rotary piston engine parts

Operating principle of the Wankel engine

Using the example of engines installed on VAZ cars, the following technical characteristics can be mentioned: - 1.308 cm3 - working volume of the RPD chamber; — 103 kW/6000 min-1 – rated power; — 130 kg engine weight; — 125,000 km – engine life before its first complete overhaul.