Surely many people think before buying a new car, what is better to buy Lada Kalina or Renault Logan, which is not so different in price. For comparison, let's take them with identical 1.6-liter engines and a 16-valve head. Let’s take a closer look at the configurations of these two machines and see which one wins in terms of the set of installed equipment and various options. So, let’s take the Kalina Universal in the Lux configuration for 386,000 rubles and the Logan in the Expression configuration costing 416,000 rubles and compare them.
Driving qualities of compared cars
We invite you to compare our competitors in terms of driving comfort; it is very difficult to assign priorities to any of these models. Both suspensions are perfectly adapted to Russian road realities and are able to confidently overcome both bumpy terrain and demonstrate stability on country roads.
An enviable ground clearance (160 mm) and enhanced standard protection of the engine compartment from below give the owner confidence while driving on bumpy and rocky areas.
Reviews from owners of Nissan Almera or Renault Logan indicate that Renault's suspension is characterized by a long service life and is less whimsical. Modest dimensions and good maneuverability make Logan nimble and able to nimbly “spin” in cramped urban “jungles”. The “Frenchman” acquired special respect among taxi drivers.
Interior of Lada Largus and Renault Logan
Regarding the external appearance of the cabin space, you can notice that in the interior Logan looks more attractive than its Russian competitor. The “European” materials are of higher quality and more pleasant to tactile manipulation. The level of equipment with comfort options is higher, which is confirmed by the multimedia complex with a large display.
The basic configuration of the “French” can be supplemented with the following options for an additional fee:
- side pillows;
- light alloy wheels;
- navigation system.
Side mirrors allow drivers of both station wagons to have good visibility.
Next up is luggage compartments. Logan’s capacity turned out to be better, because 573 liters of usable space left behind the competition of 560 liters that the Russian model can offer. Almost the same volume, so it’s difficult to choose which is better: Renault Logan or Lada Largus.
Largus “wins back” thanks to a more spacious interior. There is more room for the legs of passengers in the stern, so on long trips they are certainly endowed with sufficient comfort.
The Lagrus package also provides the possibility of installing alloy wheels, an ABS system, a driver airbag and an air conditioning system. Naturally, all this is available for some additional payment. We continue the comparison in an attempt to determine which is better than Renault Logan or Lada Largus.
Exterior body design
Assessing body design is a daunting task, as tastes vary widely among motorists. According to drivers, Renault Logan fully meets all consumer needs. They cite many reasons for this, for example, a pronounced radiator grille or an elongated body. However, Lada is practically not inferior to its competitor in this indicator. During its development, the latest fashion trends were assessed, so the specialists managed to select an attractive appearance.
Appearance
Most car enthusiasts, after reading the name, probably had doubts. Of course, the issue of the car’s appearance is ambiguous. Here, both Lada Kalina and Renault Logan are low-cost cars, so savings can be seen everywhere, even in their appearance.
Lada Kalina is a car that became AVTOVAZ’s benchmark when releasing the first generations, comparable to foreign cars. This car is a pioneer of the domestic automobile industry, having received an unusual exterior, a power unit that is an order of magnitude higher than its predecessors and meets European standards, and expanded functionality at the level of foreign expensive cars. Therefore, the comparison is quite appropriate here. Renault Logan is a small sedan that came out of the doors of the automaker in the early 2000s. The best option for traveling to work and for personal purposes. The modification turned out to be a success, and the price remained at the budget level, which immediately raised this sedan to the TOP of purchased cars in the Russian Federation.
Moreover, both cars boast identical appearance. Lada has a more streamlined design with rounded edges, which gives it a harmonious appearance. Of course, the appearance of the VAZ is not as bright as we would like, but the car looks quite decent, which foreign cars cannot always boast of. And here you can think about what is better to choose.
In addition to the modification of the station wagon, the model range of this car, starting from the second generation, has a Cross variant, which is more adapted to difficult road conditions, has good ground clearance, and also has functional body kits near the wheel arches and practical moldings on the bumpers. This is a good indicator when compared with other similar machines.
In contrast to the Cross option, which is being designed within the walls of AVTOVAZ, the French have nothing to provide. Renault Logan is made only as a sedan; the French did not expand the model range by creating hatchbacks or station wagons. In terms of appearance, there are complaints about the first generation of sedans - it is rather rough, cropped and not entirely proportional in some elements. In this regard, when answering the question of which is better, many give preference to a domestic car.
The French are ahead in this aspect. The designers have created a truly chic and bright car that fits perfectly into the urban lifestyle; in it you will not become the subject of ridicule from passers-by or drivers. The appearance has become more presentable than it was before, and when compared with competitors.
Inside, Renault Logan has also become more comfortable and has significantly outperformed VAZ’s creation in this criterion. Although the finish of both brands is not the best, it includes elements of rough plastic, but considering the cost, everything turns out to be quite logical. And here it’s difficult to immediately understand what to choose.
Vesta appearance vs Renault Logan 2 exterior
Comparison of Lada Vesta and Renault Logan 2
The French competitor looks decent, which makes it even more popular among ordinary fans. Lada Vesta was created with the intention of eradicating from the minds of buyers the idea that a car from Russia cannot look fashionable and attractive - and when looking at it, such an impression is created (even on video).
On a note!
AvtoVAZ engineers have a firm intention to expand the range of body styles, releasing a hatchback and a station wagon in the near future. At the moment, competitors creating Renault Logan 2 do not have an advantage in this aspect.
- The new product from AvtoVAZ immediately established itself as a car with a stylish design. Many called it the discovery of the year. Vesta's body is decorated with X-shaped stampings. The front part of the Russian car harmoniously combines a chrome radiator grille, headlights and front bumper, which gives great shine to the appearance. Having colorful dimensions, Lada Vesta looks very solid.
- Renault Logan 2 has a simple design. External features are straightforward and perceived unemotionally. The headlights, which are small in size, are located at an angle and harmoniously fit into the radiator grille. The car elegantly combines all body elements (front, rear and side). They note that the outlines of cheapness are visible in the external image. The Renault Logan 2 profile does not have any stampings or other fragments that emphasize its uniqueness.
On a note!
Lada Vesta, due to its novelty and aggressive dynamics, wins in the category of exterior and prestige. The car is endowed with an extraordinary appearance and is etched in the memory of potential buyers for a long time. Renault designers did not bet on what Logan 2 would look like. The car makes you notice other qualities and compare it with a car of a more attractive design.
Renault Logan
Logan is a representative of the French brand. The first copies of the now popular cars were produced in 2012.
Main characteristics of the machine:
- Ground clearance – 15.5 cm.
- Dimensions – length 4.3 m, width 1.7 m, height 1.5 m.
- Weight – 1.1 t.
- Trunk volume – 510 l.
Logan belongs to the B class car category. However, French manufacturers have solved the problem of small hatchback trunks. Some experts classify Logan's dimensions as transport category C. Its miniature dimensions and spacious trunk allow you to move around the city and travel outside without any problems.
Specifications
Lada Vesta CrossRenault Logan StepwayDimensions, weightLength, mm44244368Width, mm17851761Height, mm15261576Wheelbase, mm26352634Ground clearance, mm203195Curb weight, kg12301125Gross weight, kg16701550Trunk volume, l480 510Fuel tank volume, l5550Dynamics, efficiencyMaximum speed, km/h186172Acceleration time 0–100 km/h, s10.211, 0 Fuel consumption, l/100 km: urban cycle 9.58.8 extra-urban cycle 6.25.8 mixed cycle 7.46.8 Equipment Engine type petrol, 4-cylinder, in-line petrol, 4-cylinder, in-line Displacement, cm317741598 Power, hp at min-1122 at 5900 113 at 5500 Torque, Nm at min-1170 at 3700 152 at 4000 Transmission 5-speed, manual 5-speed, manual Drive front front Front suspension independent independent Rear suspension semi-independent semi-independent Brakes (front/rear) disc/disc disc/drum Tire size 205/50R17205/55R16Operating costs*Transport tax, r.30502825TO-1/TO-2, r.6300 / 87009600 / 9600OSAGO, r.11 0699488Casco, r.55 00050 000Currently reading: Resource of high-voltage wires Renault Logan
* Transport tax in Moscow. TO-1/TO-2 - according to the dealer. Casco and OSAGO - based on 1 male driver, single, age 30 years, driving experience 10 years.
Salon in all respects
The next stage of discussion should be the interior, since this is what is important for all family drivers. It must be said that Kalina 2 immediately disappoints the population, because only a couple of passengers can easily fit in the back seat. The one extra person becomes a problem, preventing everyone else from riding comfortably. Although even a large man does not limit himself in the front passenger seat, which became an important choice on the part of the designers.
The widespread Logan, on the contrary, gives more freedom in the back seat. Even three people feel comfortable, so the trip turns into a pleasure for them. But in the front seat, a foreign car is unlikely to allow you to relax. To do this, you will have to move completely back, and this is wrong.
Reliability is a complex indicator
The last parameter that will interest buyers should be reliability. In this area, Logan exceeds all expectations, as its service life lasts several years without repair. Accordingly, the motorist does not think about any difficulties when he gets behind the wheel of a foreign car. Of course, even Kalina 2 will not provide a long service life without repairs, so you shouldn’t hope for anything.
However, professionals say that foreign cars last so long only because of regular maintenance. It is part of the warranty, so the owner is obliged to promptly visit the boxes for computer diagnostics, oil changes and other actions. What do drivers of domestic models do? They often fail to even change the oil for years, which is why the car deteriorates, so there is no need to draw global conclusions.
Steering
Another interesting parameter is the steering. Logan usually surpasses even foreign cars in this characteristic, since its cruise control freely holds the car on almost any road surface. However, we need to remember the terrible potholes and potholes that we have to go around in our country. There’s nothing a foreign car can do here; it’s not designed for such extreme conditions.
In practice, Kalina, although it handles a little worse, still retains the right to compete. Even the lack of additional equipment does not frighten experienced drivers. They feel confident because the car can freely drive around any obstacles.
Car audio systems
These devices in both Nissan Almera and Renault Logan cars are significantly different. Rich versions of Logan have full-fledged radios that keep up with the frantic rhythm of modern fashion in the field of electronic media. The audio complex control buttons are conveniently located on the steering rim.
If you compare, the radio in Nissan is the exact opposite. It upsets owners with its inability to play programs in the long-used MP3 format. Despite the presence of touch controls, this device for the Logan radio is not a competitor. Another fly in the ointment is that there is no way to connect an external flash storage device. Let's continue the comparison.
Characteristics
Lada Kalina is a small car. Its dimensions speak about this. At the same time, in the so-called “family version” body version - a station wagon, the car has a length dimension not exceeding 4.104 m. This car has a ground clearance of almost 190 mm. This parameter is quite rare on foreign-made cars. In the usual version, the ground clearance is less significant - only 160 mm.
If we compare, the latest Renault Logan model is 300 mm longer than the LADA Kalina, and the ground clearance is a modest 160 mm. But by compensating for the difference, the designers managed to expand the capacity of the luggage compartment of the car. On a domestic car this parameter is 335 liters, while on a brand new Renault it is almost 500 liters. Although, if you fold out the rear row of seats, the Lada’s trunk capacity will increase to 670 liters.
A comparison of power units, in terms of which is better, shows that VAZ-made engines with a capacity of 87 hp. and 98 hp respectively, engines from Renault produce 87 hp. and 102 horses. The Russian car has a 16 and 8 valve engine design. At the same time, the transmission has five gears and is only mechanical. No other options are provided. For many, this will become an argument in the question of what to choose.
Car enthusiasts who prefer the French sedan have more options for alternatives. Renault Logan can be equipped with engines of 1.4 liters and 1.6 liters with 8 and 16 valves, respectively. Refueling can be done on any engine with either 92 or 95 gasoline. The car is also quite economical, which is very good when compared with its competitors.
In addition to manual transmission, the Frenchman also has an automatic transmission. In addition, starting from the second generation, in a number of models on the box you can find a decent robot that has artificial intelligence.
Budget about 20,000 rubles and a difficult choice: Logan or Kalina Cross?
“In the spring we want to buy a new car that costs plus or minus 20,000 rubles. We can't choose between Renault Logan and Lada Kalina Cross. Could you do a comparison review of these cars? How are things going with spare parts, corrosion resistance of the body, reliability of parts, engine, etc.? And compare loans."
Both models belong to the small class (European “B” segment), and are generally comparable in cost and offered consumer qualities. The same applies to the cost of ownership: with the same approach to issues of operation and maintenance, there should be no fundamental difference in costs. And this is important for the future buyer to understand: he will choose Lada Kalina Cross or Renault Logan, from the point of view of the family budget there is no fundamental difference. But, as we know, the devil is in the details. Which ones exactly in this case? We'll figure out.
Let's start with the design differences. Logan is a sedan. Yes, with a fairly spacious interior (there is plenty of space for rear passengers), a large 510-liter trunk, although not the most convenient (the hinges of its lid eat up part of the useful volume, the transformation possibilities are limited by the type of body).
Kalina Cross is a station wagon with better interior transformation capabilities and a more convenient trunk for transporting large items. True, the compact dimensions of the body predetermine the small volume of the cargo compartment (only 355 liters to the curtain). And there is a little less space for rear passengers than in Renault. In other words, the Lada is not as spacious initially, but the interior transformation capabilities are better.
The main differences between the Cross version and just Kalina are the body kit and the ground clearance increased to 183 mm. Under normal operating conditions, this is just a matter of aesthetics. But if you often drive off asphalt onto broken dirt roads, high ground clearance can be a good help. However, the Logan has only slightly less ground clearance (165 mm), and in terms of the energy intensity of the suspension and the smoothness of the ride on bad roads, it can compete with the Lada.
In terms of power units, both models are close. In both cases, buyers are offered a choice between 8- and 16-valve versions of the 1.6-liter engine. In the case of Lada it is 87 or 106 hp, in the case of Renault - 82 and 102/113 hp. Accordingly, the dynamics and fuel efficiency of similar versions are comparable. The question does not mention the type of transmission, but we can assume that it is a manual transmission. In both cases, a 5-speed manual transmission is offered. In addition, Logan can be purchased with a 4-speed automatic transmission, and Kalina Cross with a 5-speed AMT robotic transmission with one clutch. From the point of view of driving comfort, the Renault automatic transmission is preferable; from the point of view of fuel efficiency, the Lada AMT is preferable. By modern standards, both boxes are yesterday.
| Comparison of technical characteristics | ||||
| Model | Renault Logan | Lada Kalina Cross | ||
| Body type | sedan | 5-door station wagon | ||
| Length/width/height, mm | 4350/1733/1517 | 4104/1700/1560 | ||
| Wheelbase, mm | 2634 | 2476 | ||
| Ground clearance, mm | 165 | 183 | ||
| Trunk volume, l | 510 | 355-670 | ||
| Fuel tank volume, l | 50 | 50 | ||
| Drive unit | front | front | ||
| Engine | 1.6 | 1.6-16v | 1.6 | 1.6-16v |
| Engine capacity, cc | 1598 | 1598 | 1596 | 1596 |
| Power, kW (hp) at rpm | 61(82)/5000 | 83(113)/5500 | 64(87)/5100 | 78(106)/5800 |
| Maximum torque, Nm at rpm | 134/2800 | 152/4000 | 140/3800 | 148/4200 |
| Transmission | 5M | 5M | 5M | 5M |
| Acceleration time 0-100 km/h, s | 11,9 | 10,7 | 12,2 | 10,8 |
| Maximum speed, km/h | 172 | 180 | 165 | 177 |
| Fuel consumption city/highway/average, l | 9,8/5,8/7,2 | 9,4/5,6/6,6 | 9,3/6,0/6,6 | 9,0/5,8/6,5 |
We have repeatedly tested both the basic Kalina and its Cross version, as well as the second generation Logan, so we have the opportunity to compare both cars as a whole. So, in general, Logan is better. It is perceived as a European car, albeit a cheaper one. Yes, it is noisy and “gluttonous”, with peculiar ergonomics, but stable workmanship and a well-tuned chassis. In the case of Lada, each car is a little individual: in one the transmission howls more, in another it is quieter, in one the steering wheel is “transparent” in reactions and has clear feedback, in another it returns to zero reluctantly. And in small details Kalina is inferior to Logan.
| Price comparison (by price, excluding promotions) | ||||||||||
| Model | Renault Logan | Lada Kalina Cross | ||||||||
| Engine | 1.6 | 1.6-16 | 1.6 | 1.6-16 | ||||||
| Transmission | 5M | 4A | 5M | 5AMT | ||||||
| Equipment | Expression | Comfort Plus | Privilege | Privilege | Luxe | Active | Classic | Comfort | Luxe | Luxe |
| Cost, rub. | 18.000 | 20.700 | 20.900 | 22.400 | 24.300 | 22.500 | 19.290 | 19.800 | 20.550 | 19.820 |
On the other hand, Lada is cheaper. For 20,550 rubles. you can consider the Kalina Cross with a 16-valve engine (106 hp) and in the Luxe package with two airbags, climate control, heated seats, rain and light sensors, a heated windshield, an audio system and rear parking sensors. A comparable engine and slightly better equipped (with side airbags, remote engine start system) Logan in the Luxe version will cost 24,300 rubles. And in order to stay within the “plus or minus 20 thousand rubles”, you will have to abandon the 16-valve engine and choose a simpler configuration. At best, it will be a Privilege for 20,900 without a heated windshield, climate control and parking sensors. On the other hand, Logan can be purchased in its simplest version for only 18,000 rubles. (and taking into account current discounts, even for 17,000), while the price list for Kalina Cross “starts” at 19,290 rubles.
Compare loans? Conditions vary depending on the programs offered by dealers. For example, there are identical offers for Lada and Renault (see the first 4 columns of the table), and there are different ones. Their detailed analysis is a topic for a separate article.
| Comparison of loan offers | |||||||||
| Brand | Lada | Renault | Lada | Renault | Lada | ||||
| The name of the program | "Easy start" | "Minimum advance" | "Minimum bid" | "Minimum bid" | "7.99% per annum" | "11.99% per annum" | "0.01% per annum" | «13,8%» | «15,05%» |
| Currency | Belorussian rubles | ||||||||
| Advance payment | from 20% | from 50% | from 10% | ||||||
| Rate (% per annum) | 16,5% | 12,9%/16,5%* | 7,99%/14,9%* | 11,99% | 0,01%/14,88%** | 13,8%/14,8% | 15,05% | ||
| Loan terms | up to 10 years | up to 5 years | up to 4 years | up to 5 years | up to 7 years | up to 7 years | |||
| * rate first year/subsequent years | |||||||||
| ** rate for the first 6 months/subsequent months | |||||||||
Loan rates, although they have become lower, are, objectively speaking, still very high, which is especially noticeable when repayment periods are long. On the other hand, a “long” loan allows you to get a small monthly payment, and options with preferential rates in the first year and the possibility of early repayment make it possible to reduce the amount of overpayment if you pay off the loan as quickly as possible. At the same time, unlike short programs with initially large monthly payments, the buyer still has a safety net: he can immediately repay the loan in large amounts, and in the event of force majeure, limit himself to the minimum required payments.
In any case, when choosing a program and in general when deciding to use a particular financing instrument, you should not only objectively assess your capabilities, but also carefully study all the terms of the loan, leasing or installment plan agreement that is offered to you in order to accurately understand what This is exactly what it will cost to buy a car using this scheme.
Now let's talk about operational issues. As for the cost of original parts and maintenance at a company service center, several years ago we compared Lada Kalina and Renault Sandero, during which we found out that scheduled maintenance for Renault will cost less than for Lada. However, the difference was less than 10%, so it can be considered insignificant. The cost of body parts and optics will vary significantly, and with a few exceptions, not in favor of a foreign car. In general, if in the case of Kalina you can still take a risk, then for Logan it is better to immediately apply for Full CASCO!
If we talk about servicing on our own, then both models are quite simple, there is nothing complicated. Logan II represents an evolutionary development of the previous model. The car was originally developed for markets in developing countries; it is accordingly simple and well adapted to difficult operating conditions. The B0 platform uses time-tested components that were used on models of the 1990s. In turn, Kalina II is an evolution of the previous model, and it is based on technologies that were used on front-wheel drive models of the first generation VAZ-2108/09/099. Spare parts are inexpensive even from dealers, even cheaper from third-party sellers, especially for Kalina. But in the case of Lada, you need to be on your guard: as experts say, there are a lot of frankly low-quality and counterfeit parts on the market!
Reliability? Logan's fame as an "indestructible" car is somewhat exaggerated, and modern Ladas are much better than the opinion about them. If you buy a car new and operate it competently, for the first 5-6 years and 100-150 thousand km everything will come down to scheduled maintenance and replacement of worn-out consumables; if you’re not very lucky, to a couple of warranty cases. Also, Lada can be annoying with a lot of small troubles, but in big ones it should look no worse than Renault.
We'll talk about engines and gearboxes separately. Regardless of the number of valves, VAZ engines on Kalina II do not forgive a broken timing belt. Consequences - the pistons “meet” the valves, damaging the latter. In addition, there are cases where connecting rods and even the cylinder head were damaged. So it’s better not to miss the deadline for replacing the timing drive, change the rollers along with the belt, as well as the pump, use only high-quality parts. Let us repeat: there are many spare parts on the market for VAZ cars of frankly low quality, so the issue of choosing manufacturers and sellers should be taken seriously. It is believed that the service life of 1.6-liter Togliatti engines is no less than 200 thousand km; numerous operating histories confirm this.
Despite the modernization, the gearbox still likes to “noise”, but this does not affect reliability in any way. During active driving (especially in conjunction with a more powerful 16-valve engine), the second gear synchronizers wear out prematurely, making it difficult to engage this gear. With long runs, the shaft bearings may get tired.
The Renault K7M 8-valve engine has the reputation of being “eternal”. It is based on the 1.4-liter K7J (Clio, Kangoo, etc.), first used in the mid-1990s on the Renault Megane/Scenic. A cast-iron block, an aluminum head, a small degree of boost and the absence of additional systems such as a variable valve timing system or individual ignition coils make this engine simple and unpretentious, and most importantly, durable: the service life actually exceeds 400 thousand km! But there are also disadvantages - increased fuel consumption, oil leaks through the crankshaft oil seal and valve cover gasket. The timing belt drive also requires timely replacement.
The versions with manual transmission still have the 16-valve K4M (102 hp), and since 2016, cars with manual transmission have the H4M engine (aka Nissan HR16DE) with an aluminum block and a timing chain drive. The life of the chain is approximately 130-150 thousand km, then it stretches, the valve timing is lost, so this timing drive cannot be called eternal. One more nuance: replacing spark plugs requires dismantling the throttle valve assembly and the plastic intake manifold, which complicates (and increases the cost of) an otherwise ordinary operation. This engine is no longer considered “eternal”, but it definitely reaches its 300-350 thousand km. After 5-7 years and 70-80 thousand km, the throttle valve may need to be cleaned.
In terms of corrosion resistance, both models are average; without proper care, after 5-6 years the bodies will suffer from rust. However, for the first few years, the factory anticorrosive agent copes well with protection. The galvanized body of Logan resists corrosion well when chips occur, but Kalina can “bloom,” so a control inspection and prompt touch-up of damaged areas are required.
What's the result? In terms of maintenance costs, both models are approximately at the same level, so when choosing, we would recommend focusing on other parameters. For example, which car suits you best in terms of passenger and cargo capabilities, you will like it more during a test drive. And only after that should you take into account the difference in the cost of cars. Kalina Cross is cheaper, so you can either save on the purchase or buy a Lada with a better level of equipment and a more powerful engine for the same money. Or it may happen that only after “trying on” the car you will understand that it is better to pay extra and still take the more expensive Logan. Or, on the contrary, make sure that Kalina Cross is quite suitable for you. That is, in any case, the decision to choose should depend on your assessment of each of the cars.
Ivan KRISHKEVICH ABW.BY
You have questions? We have the answers. Topics that interest you will be expertly commented on by either specialists or our authors - you will see the results on the website abw.by. Leave questions on the forum or use the “Write to the Editor” button
Cabin canopy
Looking at the Lada from the outside, you will be able to understand that even the new body design could not have a positive effect on the body canopy. Unfortunately, the driver's visibility remains limited, so you need to prepare for difficulties in advance. Fans of the domestic automobile industry have long been accustomed to this, but connoisseurs of foreign cars will encounter difficulties.
Convenient Logan is inferior in this parameter only to some of the latest models of foreign brands. In it you can freely see the entire surrounding space from the driver's seat, and even stopping right under a traffic light does not limit your view. It turns out that the trip becomes more comfortable and interesting.
Internal equipment
The luggage compartment capacity of the Logan corresponds to 510 liters, which is comparable to the luggage compartments of business class models. In this parameter, Kalina also loses: the capacity of its luggage compartment is 260 liters (for a hatchback) and 361 liters (for a station wagon).
Inside the Lada Kalina 2 is much more interesting than its competitor in this review
The seating position in both cars is quite comfortable. While driving Logan, you can freely change the lift and lumbar support, but the reach of the steering wheel is not adjustable. The driver's seat in the “second” Kalina is more functional in terms of settings; the steering wheel can be changed according to the reach.
Currently reading: Renault Logan or Lada Vesta, which is better: step-by-step instructions
Due to the fact that in the Renault Logan the gearbox lever immediately fits into the grooves, changing gears is much more pleasant, but when sitting in Kalina, due to the free movement of the lever, sometimes doubts arise as to whether the shift lever is correctly placed in the desired gear.
The Renault Logan salon is imbued with minimalism
The control levers in a Russian car are located ergonomically; we can say that they ideally occupy their places. In the Logan model, the designers did not provide for convenient viewing of data on the dashboard regarding temperature data and the fuel level limit in the tank due to their non-ergonomic arrangement.
Comfort:
A domestic car has: air conditioning; heated front seats; anti-theft system with remote control; electric windows for both front and rear doors; heated and electrically adjustable exterior mirrors; audio system with 4 speakers and antenna
And now attention to Renault: you need to pay an additional 25,000 rubles for installing an air conditioner; pay 9,000 rubles on top for the radio; mirrors will have to be adjusted manually; The rear windows also need to be lowered the old-fashioned way with a handle; and there is no heating, no mirrors, no front seats; There is nothing here to protect against theft, only a regular central lock, which can be locked with a key.
If I forgot to mention something, then obviously it will not be a plus for a foreign car. Now let’s do the math, add the same 4300 + 19800 + 25000 + 9000 to the cost of Renault. And it turns out that you need to pay another 53,800 rubles to the original price of Logan in order to get at least something close in configuration to the luxury Kalina. In total, it turns out that our Logan will cost 474,100 rubles, which is 88,100 more than our Lada. But even with such a huge difference in price, the domestic car is completely superior to its competitor.
Description Renault Logan
Replacing the front wheel bearing r km: Replacing the front brake pads r km: Replacing the driver's power window gear motor r km: Replacing the trunk lock r km: Repairing the inside handle of the right passenger door yourself km: Replacing the steering tips r. Changing the oil in the box r km: Replacing the brake fluid level sensor r km: Replacing the driver's door handle r km: Replacing the rear light connector r km: Replacing a broken alternator belt r km: Replacing the thermostat r km: LADA Kalina is a modest thing, so filling the car to a minimum, and the filling itself is of average functionality.
But, in fairness, the car has the whole range of options that are in demand by modern drivers: The French sedan has no less optional filling. The first models had functionality similar to their domestic counterpart.
At the same time, the latest modification of this French brainchild has more advanced functionality. Even a luxury car from any foreign automaker can envy the options received.
Kalina is a car that has the most modest configuration, and therefore you won’t be able to see an overly rich functional filling here. However, there is literally everything that can be useful to a modern driver, electric windows, heated mirrors, power steering, on-board computer - this is not all that can be found in a car in the most expensive configuration.
The Frenchman also did not disappoint, and the equipment here is quite tolerable. If we talk about the first generation of the sedan, then the equipment here is similar to that of the representative of the Russian automobile industry. True, even in the basic version you can find airbags, without which it is impossible to imagine any modern car.
The new generation of this foreign car has a rich set of options that many representatives of foreign production can envy. In some versions you will be able to find climate control and even a multimedia system with a navigation function. Final verdict Both presented cars are worthy representatives of the budget price class.
Possessing unconditional reliability, they are able to survive for a long time without unscheduled repairs. Every motorist should have a universal device for removing scratches on a car of any color.
Usually there are several suitable cars, and then the question arises, which one to choose: The cost of these cars is relatively close, but how different are their characteristics? Appearance At first glance, we can say that both cars look modern and stylish, and it cannot be said that the Renault Logan is more impressive in appearance than the Kalina 2 or vice versa.
Features of movement
When considering the dynamics of Kalina 2 and Renault Logan, one can highlight their similarities. Both cars reach the acceleration mark to the first hundred in 13 seconds. To objectively compare the dynamic characteristics of representatives of the models under consideration, cars with manual transmissions were used. In addition, the technical indicators declared by the automaker corresponded to the actual indicators.
The Renault Logan drives over uneven surfaces more confidently. Logan also earns extra points in soundproofing. A distinct noise usually occurs only with a dynamic increase in speed from 3500 per minute. The sound from the running engine of Kalina 2 gives it away already at idle.
Main driving characteristics
Consideration of driving performance is usually not of interest to consumers. They are confident that Renault Logan will be better in all respects, so they don’t even look at Lada. Only they will make a big mistake, not imagining what perfection the Tolyatti designers have created.
The maximum speed for Kalina is 175 kilometers per hour, but Renault Logan will allow you to reach no more than 162. You can feel a colossal difference, which will certainly amaze fans of fast driving. If you want to really accelerate on the highway, you should buy a domestic car that allows you to easily outperform your competitors.
Is the car really just as good in other respects? In its lightweight configuration, Kalina reaches 100 kilometers per hour in 12.2 seconds, and in the basic version – in 13. How does Logan behave? On its speedometer, 100 kilometers per hour will also appear after 13 seconds, so no driver will notice a noticeable difference.
This comparative characteristic shows that when buying a car you don’t have to look closely at this parameter. Although in all respects the domestic model is much more interesting. She may be far from a foreign powerful sports car, but the man will be able to show himself on the road, greatly surprising all the surrounding drivers. It will quickly accelerate to high speeds, beating numerous competitors.
Price
In terms of price, Renault Logan surpasses Lada Kalina 2 by at least $1000.
When choosing between Logan and Kalina 2, you need to carefully compare the disadvantages and positive features of each car. The Russian model costs less and is therefore more economically profitable. The minimum set of options in the Kalina 2 configuration is offered for $7,500, and the maximum for $10,000. The price level for the 2014 Renault Logan is set at $8,000 – $11,000.
Compared to its competitor, Renault Logan captivates potential buyers with its comfortable and spacious interior, high level of handling, as well as noise insulation characteristics. Two factors may raise doubts about purchasing a Logan model: the price of a new car and the cost of consumables for undergoing regulated maintenance.
But for Kalina, maintenance will be budget-friendly: the model was designed in Tolyatti, so the domestic iron horse will be repaired at any maintenance base, and you won’t even have to wait long for parts. In addition, the ground clearance of Kalina 2 is much greater - this is important for driving on domestic roads. You can increase the level of comfort in Kalina by simply installing additional sound insulation.
Therefore, which car is preferable, from the point of view of the arguments presented, there is no doubt.
Lada Kalina 2 comes out the winner of this review
Comparison of vehicles
The cars in question belong to the class of compact, budget vehicles. The presented cars are quite popular in Russia. The technical specifications are approximately the same.
The design of the vehicles is modern. Automakers have done a solid job of improving the appearance. They note that Renault Logan is more impressive and interesting in design. Elements of solidity are added by a large radiator grille and presentable optics. Kalina is inferior to its opponent in terms of external characteristics: it lacks original inserts to make the car recognizable and expressive.
The interior space of the Kalina leaves much to be desired: there is not enough space, the interior is cramped, and can hardly accommodate three passengers in the back seat. Logan's interior is comfortable and spacious.
The technical equipment of cars is different. The standard package of Kalina includes:
- Airbag opposite the driver's seat.
- Power steering.
- Possibility of adjusting the driver's seat.
- Electric window lifts (front).
- Folding passenger rear seats.
Logan's equipment is distinguished by the installation of an ABS anti-lock braking system and static seats without the possibility of folding. The car in its basic assembly is safer than its opponent.
The cost of vehicles varies. The basic version of the Lada Kalina will cost approximately 420 thousand rubles. Renault Logan in standard configuration is sold for 470 thousand rubles. The difference of 50 thousand is overestimated, since the technical characteristics of the cars are approximately the same.
Both cars have Luxury configurations. As the level of equipment increases, the reliability and safety of the vehicle increases. Thus, in the highest configuration, Kalina is equipped with ABS. ESP. airbags. climate control system. power steering. computer. heated seats. all kinds of automatic buttons to adjust the steering wheel, seats and make driving easier. fog lights. The price for the luxury category will increase by 120 thousand rubles from the basic cost.
Logan of the highest configuration is equipped with ABS. ESP. airbags. climate control system. computer. remote control. power accessories, heated mirrors and seats. fog lights. adjustable steering column. cruise control. a complex of assistance when climbing uphill. Such improvements will require an additional payment of 270 thousand rubles.
Lada Kalina “Lux” has a power of 106 horsepower, reaches a maximum speed of 175 km per hour, and accelerates to 100 km in 12.9 seconds. It consumes 8.6 liters of fuel per 100 km.
Renault Logan “Lux” has a power of 102 horsepower, reaches a maximum speed of 171 km per hour, and accelerates to 100 km in 11.7 seconds. It consumes 10.9 liters of fuel per 100 km.
Engines
Despite the fact that a domestic car has the opportunity to offer the buyer only one power unit, and the French have two power options, of these three engines the most powerful is the domestic unit.
As for the French car, it has an 8-valve option. Despite the 1.6-liter capacity and a special fuel injection system, the car’s output was only 82 horsepower. The car operates at 5000 rpm, but the car's torque is 134 Nm.
Despite this, Renault's dynamics are quite good. The car has the ability to accelerate to 100 kilometers per hour in 11.9 seconds. As for the maximum speed of the car, not everything is so great here. The indicator was only 172 kilometers per hour. Fuel consumption in this case is too high for such a unit: 9.5, 7.2 and 5.8 liters for the city, highway, general type.
As for the second version of the French car, there is a unit that operated at a power of 102 horsepower. There is already an option for 16 valves. Among other things, the revolutions are 5750 indicators. As for traction, everything has changed a little here too.
Vesta engine
A domestic car has the opportunity to use only one available option. In this case, there is a domestically produced 1.6-liter engine operating at a power of 102 horsepower. As for this version with 16 valves, the power is 106 horsepower.
The torque in this case is 148 Nm. As for the dynamics of the car, not everything is so great here, the difference with the Frenchman was only -0.1 seconds, and in this case we are talking about a weaker version with 82 horsepower. The Lada Vesta is inferior to the second version of the car by 1.3 seconds. As for the car’s efficiency indicator, everything here is also almost on par with Renault – 9.3/6.9/5.5 liters.
In these indicators, Vesta is slightly inferior to the French version of the car. However, this is only for a while, because very soon an option with 110 horsepower will appear. In addition, a 1.8-liter version of the unit will soon appear, which will already have 122 horsepower.
Moreover, there will also be a completely budget version of the engine with a power of 87 horsepower. It is for these reasons that the Russian sedan will soon significantly surpass the Frenchman in all respects. Therefore, in this regard, the choice of which is better: Lada Vesta or Renault Logan is obvious.
Exterior of the French Logan and domestic Grant
Let us immediately note that there is no point in comparing these Lada Granta or Renault Logan cars with representatives of more expensive and prestigious segments, because one cannot expect dizzying characteristics and capabilities from our rivals. Both Granta and Logan are suitable for such clients who do not have a thirst for chasing status, prestige and high cost.
For its market niche, Lada turned out to be a very successful and balanced product, having managed to acquire enviable popularity since 2011. This modification is chosen not only by pensioners, but also by practical young people. Thanks to the wide range of colors of the “Russian” body, everyone will be able to choose the best option for themselves according to their taste. The interior decoration is made well and without much luxury for the sake of maximum practicality.
Regarding Logan, let’s say that it was introduced to the market earlier than the Russian model (in 2005), and already in 2014 it experienced its generational change. The appearance of the “Frenchman” is characterized as more restrained and closer to the classic. The balance of consumer properties contributed to wide popularity among representatives of different social classes. Entering the cabin, you immediately understand that the model belongs to the European school of automotive engineering. To understand what to choose, you will have to compare other aspects.
Features of the body and aerodynamics of the Grant and Logan
In 2022, a series of cars with a liftback body was released for the first time on the Russian market. A special feature of this body is that, despite the spacious trunk, like in a sedan, the car still has five doors, which allows you to easily get into the cabin from the trunk.
This is useful when there is a need for additional cargo space. They may not have been ready to present the Lada in this form, but the Russian buyer really liked it. The well-thought-out aerodynamics of the car make it look elegant and attractive.
In 2022, Renault presented a very similar model in appearance, it only looked a little more modern. Lada Granta or Renault Logan - in this matter it is certainly a matter of taste, and, probably, family status. A liftback will help you cope with many tasks when moving or traveling out of town with the whole family.
The most popular tire size in Russia is diameter 14. This is the basic size that the Lada manufacturer offers in 2021. Logan, in turn, offers the less popular size 15. Which is better, we can only guess.
From the manufacturer’s point of view, everything is selected optimally, but still, the arch height of any car is well designed for size 15 tires. The maximum speed that Logan can reach according to its body characteristics is 172 km/h. While Lada offers a maximum speed of 176 km/h in the Grant model.
Bottom line: which car to choose?
Vehicles are relatively inexpensive and popular in Russia. Each of the presented cars will become a reliable means of transportation and travel. It is necessary to decide in advance for what purposes the transport will be used.
If you prefer a budget option and are willing to make room in a compact interior with a relatively small trunk, then choose Kalina. One should not be biased towards domestic production; the Russian car is not inferior in technical characteristics to its imported opponent. Fuel consumption and maintenance costs will be slightly cheaper.
Logan is suitable for cozy trips with the whole family or city driving. The price of a foreign car is higher. However, the increase in cost is offset by the comfort provided by the car and safety.
Kalina and Logan appeared on the Russian market relatively recently - in 2013 and 2012, respectively. Both cars belong to the budget segment of class B (compact). In 2013, their prices were almost equal, but the financial crisis took its toll - Renault Logan became more expensive, since imported parts are used in its production. However, the difference in price is not that big and amounts to no more than 50,000 rubles, if we compare the minimum configurations of cars.
Lada Kalina and Renault Logan - budget B class cars
Both cars have a large number of sales in Russia. Renault Logan is the best-selling car on our market - the model occupies a record 4% of all vehicles on the market. As for the Lada Kalina, many drivers express skepticism about it, since the stereotype about the poor quality of Russian cars has not yet been completely destroyed. However, Kalina has excellent quality and equipment for its price, which cannot but please lovers of savings.
A driver who decides to buy a budget car from segment B most likely chooses between Lada Kalina and Renault Logan, because they are leaders in the class. However, comparing appearance, price and stated characteristics is not enough. Purchasing a car is a serious undertaking where it is highly undesirable to make a mistake. Car enthusiasts choosing between Kalina and Logan are advised to study a detailed comparison of cars.
Comfort of compared cars
Renault Logan 2022 is equipped with a multimedia instrument panel. This panel has full touch controls. Even the base model has climate control. This makes the car an inherently luxurious experience within the car.
At this point, the Lada Granta is significantly inferior, because air conditioning is an additional option that costs money. A significant advantage of both cars is the presence of running lights, but in Renault they are automatically turned on with the ignition, which undoubtedly allows you not to worry about safety.
Renault has electric window lifts for all four doors, while Lada has factory lifts only for the front two. The advantage for the Lada Granta manufacturers is that in 2021 they decided to release a model with athermal glass. For our winter conditions this is the best option.
The air conditioner was mentioned above, but Russian designers turned out to be enterprising and installed an air purification filter in the ventilation system. Renault Logan does not provide this; the air is purified through an air conditioner, which means its maintenance is more expensive, since freon will need to be replaced. Renault Logan 2022 surprises with how much is provided in the car’s interior, this also applies to the audio system:
- It is mounted directly into the dashboard, which is made of material reminiscent of Alcantara. The audio system is equipped with all speakers, including the possibility of using an additional subwoofer.
- Plays all possible formats today, from any media.
But the Lada Granta 2022 is equipped with only audio preparation. This could have a significant impact on vehicle sales in 2022. Europeans treated the consumer more responsibly in this matter. This is a small thing that does not in any way affect the technical characteristics of the car, but significantly adjusts the economic success.
Few words were said about the salon. Lada Granta has a limited choice of fabric colors. As for the body, only eight color options are offered, four of which are metallic. Renault wins here. Any color can be ordered in metallic or matte. In 2022, Renault really took care of the comfort of the driver and passengers.
The interior features heated front seats, front and side windows. Also, for ease of driving, all access to the audio system is on the steering wheel.
The steering wheel is adjustable, it has a so-called servo-steering suspension. It is very convenient and has not two positions, but four, so it can be adjusted both up and down, and away from you and towards you, which is not in the basic configuration of the Lada car.
Although the Lada Granta car has an immobilizer, Renault Logan is several generations ahead of the domestic auto industry. Logan offers remote controlled central locking.
Bottom line: which car to choose?
Vehicles are relatively inexpensive and popular in Russia. Each of the presented cars will become a reliable means of transportation and travel. It is necessary to decide in advance for what purposes the transport will be used.
If you prefer a budget option and are willing to make room in a compact interior with a relatively small trunk, then choose Kalina. One should not be biased towards domestic production; the Russian car is not inferior in technical characteristics to its imported opponent. Fuel consumption and maintenance costs will be slightly cheaper.
Logan is suitable for cozy trips with the whole family or city driving. The price of a foreign car is higher. However, the increase in cost is offset by the comfort provided by the car and safety.
Let's sum it up
Today, representatives of the budget market segment of cars have rapidly burst into the life of the average person. Although compared to expensive brands, there is some inconvenience associated with cases when the dealer does not have a modification you like, but such a car is not capable of burdening the future owner with expensive repairs and maintenance. The question of what to choose is always acute. Choose a car according to your capabilities and remember that Granta today can compete with foreign “state employees”. Well, what is actually better is up to you to decide.
